OverviewFilesCommitsIssuesDocsReleasesPeers

atomspace-layer-discovery commits / 88245fa

experiments/level2: Test LV results — Linas's clusterer at 200/100 covers too little to be a layer
L1-L3 FAIL, L4 PASS (+0.013). Scorer fix: L-MST reference now reads the MST row (was MPG); no verdict changed. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
88245fa23aeeadc1b1b3b4bcd1fd594b75a3d768
by plankatron <fleeky@gmail.com> · 2026-10-18T23:44:42.000Z

Changed files (15) +1077 -1

experiments/level2/RESULTS-LV.md +27 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
1# Test LV — Linas's clusterer as layer 1 — results
2
3Run `results-LV/1792366731` (code `1f8e6b6`, 10 seeds). Scored against PREREG-LV (`bd0d982`) by `summarize-LV.py`. Scorer fix
4before reading the verdicts: the L-MST reference first picked up Test A-U's MPG row (0.680); it now reads the MST
5row (0.700), as pre-registered. No verdict changed.
6
7| | prediction (30K) | verdict |
8|---|---|---|
9| L1 | a token's own LV-I class beats one label per word on senses | **FAIL** +0.003 [−0.004, +0.011] |
10| L2 | MST over LV-I labels beats the word MST | **FAIL** −0.026 (0.544 vs 0.570) |
11| L3 | LV-I within 0.02 of the exchange classes' parse | **FAIL** −0.156 (0.544 vs 0.700) |
12| L4 | LV-I helps level 2 (ucomp type recall vs word MST) | **PASS** +0.013 (0.267 vs 0.254) |
13
14Held-out labels at 30K (V-measure / many-to-one / labels / share of tokens in a class / sense):
15LV-I 0.658 / 0.759 / 1,190 / 0.47 / 0.753; LV-A (as Linas's stack runs) 0.722 / 0.918 / 1,170 / 0.26 / 0.828.
16Merges: 100 of 100 loops at 10K and 30K (the loop limit, not the MI cutoff, ended the run).
17
18## What it says
19
201. **Under Linas's own call the clusterer covers too little to be a layer.**
21 About half the tokens (LV-I) or a quarter (LV-A) get a class; the rest stay as single words, so there are
22 ~1,200 labels and the class-pair MI is nearly as sparse as word MI. The re-parse is slightly *worse* than words.
232. **No per-occurrence sense effect** (L1): the partial-merge mechanism does not separate senses at this scale.
24 LV-A's high many-to-one (0.92) is word identity, not good classes.
253. **This tests the documented setting, not the method's ceiling.** 100 loops hit the limit; Linas runs his
26 clustering far longer. Running to convergence (more loops, all words ranked) is the fair next test of the
27 method; its cost is unknown. Round 2 onward of the port is still unverified against Linas (parked divergence).
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/commit.txt +1 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1 @@
11f8e6b6b97ab56483d2009fd9cad1b388005bfd3
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-1.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 1 3000 LV-I 0.60496 0.69281 1190 0.57021 0.62558 0.62791
2N 1 3000 LV-I 95
3Q 1 3000 LV-A 0.72050 0.93596 1220 0.14932 0.88295 0.88295
4N 1 3000 LV-A 58
5Q 1 10000 LV-I 0.65444 0.74329 1192 0.48658 0.66538 0.84333
6N 1 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 1 10000 LV-A 0.72813 0.93870 1187 0.22938 0.86331 0.86396
8N 1 10000 LV-A 100
9Q 1 30000 LV-I 0.67779 0.79123 1205 0.45767 0.88050 0.88050
10N 1 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 1 30000 LV-A 0.72241 0.92918 1194 0.27342 0.82642 0.82642
12N 1 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=1 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=5002 kept=5002 gold=5002
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=5002 conn=5002 comp=5002
16# tier=3000 train_toks=22033
17P 1 3000 LV-I MST 0.44151 0.44151 0.44151
18X 1 3000 C-LV-I 2 6479
19X 1 3000 C-LV-I 3 10935
20X 1 3000 C-LV-I 4 11727
21X 1 3000 C-LV-I 5 10111
22X 1 3000 C-LV-I 6 7898
23A 1 3000 C-LV-I 47150 1.00000 0.57430 0.17954 4825 15434
24X 1 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 951
25X 1 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1379
26X 1 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1719
27X 1 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1866
28X 1 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1515
29A 1 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7430 0.37078 0.15855 0.32875 4825 2327
30# tier=10000 train_toks=72741
31P 1 10000 LV-I MST 0.48429 0.48429 0.48429
32X 1 10000 C-LV-I 2 15345
33X 1 10000 C-LV-I 3 31240
34X 1 10000 C-LV-I 4 36298
35X 1 10000 C-LV-I 5 32457
36X 1 10000 C-LV-I 6 25512
37A 1 10000 C-LV-I 140852 1.00000 0.63358 0.16835 4825 18159
38X 1 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2439
39X 1 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4446
40X 1 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5744
41X 1 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6211
42X 1 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5171
43A 1 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 24011 0.37637 0.19710 0.30000 4825 3170
44# tier=30000 train_toks=217958
45P 1 30000 LV-I MST 0.53913 0.53913 0.53913
46X 1 30000 C-LV-I 2 31823
47X 1 30000 C-LV-I 3 71393
48X 1 30000 C-LV-I 4 96159
49X 1 30000 C-LV-I 5 92437
50X 1 30000 C-LV-I 6 75241
51A 1 30000 C-LV-I 367053 1.00000 0.71171 0.15738 4825 21820
52X 1 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 5130
53X 1 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 12011
54X 1 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 17535
55X 1 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 19570
56X 1 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16438
57A 1 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 70684 0.41223 0.27358 0.30261 4825 4362
58# seed=1 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=5002 kept=5002 gold=5002
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=5002 conn=5002 comp=5002
61# tier=3000 train_toks=22033
62P 1 3000 LV-A MST 0.45127 0.45127 0.45127
63X 1 3000 C-LV-A 2 8266
64X 1 3000 C-LV-A 3 13056
65X 1 3000 C-LV-A 4 12461
66X 1 3000 C-LV-A 5 10298
67X 1 3000 C-LV-A 6 7920
68A 1 3000 C-LV-A 52001 1.00000 0.43399 0.17811 4825 11757
69X 1 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1210
70X 1 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1440
71X 1 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1656
72X 1 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1767
73X 1 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1518
74A 1 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7591 0.37244 0.12456 0.33688 4825 1784
75# tier=10000 train_toks=72741
76P 1 10000 LV-A MST 0.52040 0.52040 0.52040
77X 1 10000 C-LV-A 2 17462
78X 1 10000 C-LV-A 3 35373
79X 1 10000 C-LV-A 4 37986
80X 1 10000 C-LV-A 5 33000
81X 1 10000 C-LV-A 6 25593
82A 1 10000 C-LV-A 149414 1.00000 0.56166 0.16565 4825 16360
83X 1 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 2988
84X 1 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 4902
85X 1 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 5932
86X 1 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6243
87X 1 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5270
88A 1 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25335 0.42238 0.20642 0.33057 4825 3013
89# tier=30000 train_toks=217958
90P 1 30000 LV-A MST 0.57151 0.57151 0.57151
91X 1 30000 C-LV-A 2 34825
92X 1 30000 C-LV-A 3 86049
93X 1 30000 C-LV-A 4 105453
94X 1 30000 C-LV-A 5 96738
95X 1 30000 C-LV-A 6 76264
96A 1 30000 C-LV-A 399329 1.00000 0.64104 0.15792 4825 19586
97X 1 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 6728
98X 1 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 14639
99X 1 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 18495
100X 1 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 19320
101X 1 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16205
102A 1 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 75387 0.46321 0.27440 0.34372 4825 3852
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-10.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 10 3000 LV-I 0.61570 0.69228 1153 0.54788 0.66722 0.66722
2N 10 3000 LV-I 97
3Q 10 3000 LV-A 0.71951 0.93162 1210 0.13532 0.82907 0.82907
4N 10 3000 LV-A 48
5Q 10 10000 LV-I 0.63506 0.69916 1159 0.52250 0.65068 0.62055
6N 10 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 10 10000 LV-A 0.72584 0.91297 1139 0.25942 0.84110 0.84110
8N 10 10000 LV-A 100
9Q 10 30000 LV-I 0.67882 0.81075 1157 0.43568 0.81322 0.81254
10N 10 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 10 30000 LV-A 0.71608 0.91057 1162 0.20246 0.81457 0.81457
12N 10 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=10 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=4978 kept=4978 gold=4978
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=4978 conn=4978 comp=4978
16# tier=3000 train_toks=21781
17P 10 3000 LV-I MST 0.45860 0.45860 0.45860
18X 10 3000 C-LV-I 2 6175
19X 10 3000 C-LV-I 3 10552
20X 10 3000 C-LV-I 4 11394
21X 10 3000 C-LV-I 5 9810
22X 10 3000 C-LV-I 6 7601
23A 10 3000 C-LV-I 45532 1.00000 0.58881 0.17401 4808 16269
24X 10 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 868
25X 10 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1387
26X 10 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1785
27X 10 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1872
28X 10 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1598
29A 10 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7510 0.37438 0.16847 0.31727 4808 2553
30# tier=10000 train_toks=72856
31P 10 10000 LV-I MST 0.51883 0.51883 0.51883
32X 10 10000 C-LV-I 2 14341
33X 10 10000 C-LV-I 3 28661
34X 10 10000 C-LV-I 4 35039
35X 10 10000 C-LV-I 5 32013
36X 10 10000 C-LV-I 6 25383
37A 10 10000 C-LV-I 135437 1.00000 0.65537 0.16260 4808 19379
38X 10 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2144
39X 10 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4242
40X 10 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5789
41X 10 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6302
42X 10 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5397
43A 10 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 23874 0.41473 0.22983 0.30208 4808 3658
44# tier=30000 train_toks=218274
45P 10 30000 LV-I MST 0.55297 0.55297 0.55297
46X 10 30000 C-LV-I 2 33601
47X 10 30000 C-LV-I 3 76253
48X 10 30000 C-LV-I 4 99506
49X 10 30000 C-LV-I 5 93899
50X 10 30000 C-LV-I 6 75598
51A 10 30000 C-LV-I 378857 1.00000 0.67533 0.15298 4808 21225
52X 10 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 5696
53X 10 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 12419
54X 10 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 17321
55X 10 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 18996
56X 10 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16715
57A 10 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 71147 0.40557 0.24896 0.28588 4808 4187
58# seed=10 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=4978 kept=4978 gold=4978
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=4978 conn=4978 comp=4978
61# tier=3000 train_toks=21781
62P 10 3000 LV-A MST 0.46083 0.46083 0.46083
63X 10 3000 C-LV-A 2 8367
64X 10 3000 C-LV-A 3 13122
65X 10 3000 C-LV-A 4 12358
66X 10 3000 C-LV-A 5 10045
67X 10 3000 C-LV-A 6 7623
68A 10 3000 C-LV-A 51515 1.00000 0.43199 0.17666 4808 11757
69X 10 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1224
70X 10 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1433
71X 10 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1669
72X 10 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1774
73X 10 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1547
74A 10 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7647 0.37542 0.12001 0.31478 4808 1833
75# tier=10000 train_toks=72856
76P 10 10000 LV-A MST 0.52896 0.52896 0.52896
77X 10 10000 C-LV-A 2 17124
78X 10 10000 C-LV-A 3 34649
79X 10 10000 C-LV-A 4 37828
80X 10 10000 C-LV-A 5 32947
81X 10 10000 C-LV-A 6 25528
82A 10 10000 C-LV-A 148076 1.00000 0.56240 0.16147 4808 16746
83X 10 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 2876
84X 10 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 4838
85X 10 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 5889
86X 10 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6156
87X 10 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5339
88A 10 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25098 0.42575 0.20403 0.31133 4808 3151
89# tier=30000 train_toks=218274
90P 10 30000 LV-A MST 0.57052 0.57052 0.57052
91X 10 30000 C-LV-A 2 36377
92X 10 30000 C-LV-A 3 87907
93X 10 30000 C-LV-A 4 107109
94X 10 30000 C-LV-A 5 97364
95X 10 30000 C-LV-A 6 76447
96A 10 30000 C-LV-A 405204 1.00000 0.62292 0.15400 4808 19448
97X 10 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 7364
98X 10 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 14614
99X 10 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 18596
100X 10 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 19100
101X 10 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16358
102A 10 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 76032 0.43823 0.24168 0.30635 4808 3793
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-2.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 2 3000 LV-I 0.59903 0.69549 1166 0.56560 0.79163 0.79163
2N 2 3000 LV-I 100
3Q 2 3000 LV-A 0.71253 0.90834 1181 0.18352 0.79070 0.79070
4N 2 3000 LV-A 76
5Q 2 10000 LV-I 0.61593 0.70930 1182 0.54607 0.64710 0.81077
6N 2 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 2 10000 LV-A 0.72832 0.94265 1176 0.17034 0.85290 0.85290
8N 2 10000 LV-A 84
9Q 2 30000 LV-I 0.66505 0.76368 1177 0.50086 0.62993 0.63129
10N 2 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 2 30000 LV-A 0.71757 0.91538 1162 0.29505 0.83469 0.83605
12N 2 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=2 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=5023 kept=5023 gold=5023
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=5023 conn=5023 comp=5023
16# tier=3000 train_toks=21780
17P 2 3000 LV-I MST 0.45632 0.45632 0.45632
18X 2 3000 C-LV-I 2 6195
19X 2 3000 C-LV-I 3 10504
20X 2 3000 C-LV-I 4 11259
21X 2 3000 C-LV-I 5 9768
22X 2 3000 C-LV-I 6 7574
23A 2 3000 C-LV-I 45300 1.00000 0.56772 0.16969 4814 16106
24X 2 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 865
25X 2 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1417
26X 2 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1714
27X 2 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1867
28X 2 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1612
29A 2 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7475 0.36726 0.16140 0.30895 4814 2515
30# tier=10000 train_toks=72490
31P 2 10000 LV-I MST 0.49468 0.49468 0.49468
32X 2 10000 C-LV-I 2 14894
33X 2 10000 C-LV-I 3 30620
34X 2 10000 C-LV-I 4 36162
35X 2 10000 C-LV-I 5 32265
36X 2 10000 C-LV-I 6 25254
37A 2 10000 C-LV-I 139195 1.00000 0.62256 0.16568 4814 18089
38X 2 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2259
39X 2 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4368
40X 2 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5700
41X 2 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6182
42X 2 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5312
43A 2 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 23821 0.35064 0.17034 0.26554 4814 3088
44# tier=30000 train_toks=218306
45P 2 30000 LV-I MST 0.54848 0.54848 0.54848
46X 2 30000 C-LV-I 2 30265
47X 2 30000 C-LV-I 3 67644
48X 2 30000 C-LV-I 4 93545
49X 2 30000 C-LV-I 5 91140
50X 2 30000 C-LV-I 6 74907
51A 2 30000 C-LV-I 357501 1.00000 0.71437 0.15084 4814 22799
52X 2 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 4949
53X 2 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 11196
54X 2 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 17322
55X 2 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 19353
56X 2 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16431
57A 2 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 69251 0.42252 0.27669 0.30054 4814 4432
58# seed=2 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=5023 kept=5023 gold=5023
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=5023 conn=5023 comp=5023
61# tier=3000 train_toks=21780
62P 2 3000 LV-A MST 0.46201 0.46201 0.46201
63X 2 3000 C-LV-A 2 7929
64X 2 3000 C-LV-A 3 12696
65X 2 3000 C-LV-A 4 12201
66X 2 3000 C-LV-A 5 10019
67X 2 3000 C-LV-A 6 7606
68A 2 3000 C-LV-A 50451 1.00000 0.43228 0.16967 4814 12265
69X 2 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1132
70X 2 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1408
71X 2 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1619
72X 2 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1779
73X 2 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1577
74A 2 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7515 0.37183 0.11986 0.30955 4814 1864
75# tier=10000 train_toks=72490
76P 2 10000 LV-A MST 0.52614 0.52614 0.52614
77X 2 10000 C-LV-A 2 18163
78X 2 10000 C-LV-A 3 36319
79X 2 10000 C-LV-A 4 38343
80X 2 10000 C-LV-A 5 32951
81X 2 10000 C-LV-A 6 25336
82A 2 10000 C-LV-A 151112 1.00000 0.53511 0.16159 4814 15942
83X 2 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 3096
84X 2 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 5076
85X 2 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 5957
86X 2 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6250
87X 2 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5370
88A 2 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25749 0.41525 0.19589 0.31890 4814 2957
89# tier=30000 train_toks=218306
90P 2 30000 LV-A MST 0.56522 0.56522 0.56522
91X 2 30000 C-LV-A 2 36169
92X 2 30000 C-LV-A 3 89689
93X 2 30000 C-LV-A 4 106901
94X 2 30000 C-LV-A 5 97055
95X 2 30000 C-LV-A 6 76426
96A 2 30000 C-LV-A 406240 1.00000 0.62609 0.15498 4814 19448
97X 2 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 7228
98X 2 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 14929
99X 2 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 19065
100X 2 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 19650
101X 2 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16600
102A 2 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 77472 0.44308 0.25654 0.31937 4814 3867
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-3.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 3 3000 LV-I 0.64380 0.73850 1190 0.53515 0.73638 0.78846
2N 3 3000 LV-I 89
3Q 3 3000 LV-A 0.71983 0.93536 1232 0.28113 0.90304 0.90304
4N 3 3000 LV-A 57
5Q 3 10000 LV-I 0.64889 0.72648 1179 0.51957 0.83784 0.83922
6N 3 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 3 10000 LV-A 0.72125 0.91516 1172 0.37317 0.79626 0.79626
8N 3 10000 LV-A 100
9Q 3 30000 LV-I 0.67390 0.78281 1210 0.46632 0.87957 0.87957
10N 3 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 3 30000 LV-A 0.71837 0.90846 1168 0.27023 0.81258 0.81326
12N 3 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=3 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=4908 kept=4908 gold=4908
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=4908 conn=4908 comp=4908
16# tier=3000 train_toks=21946
17P 3 3000 LV-I MST 0.45272 0.45272 0.45272
18X 3 3000 C-LV-I 2 6769
19X 3 3000 C-LV-I 3 11253
20X 3 3000 C-LV-I 4 11694
21X 3 3000 C-LV-I 5 10038
22X 3 3000 C-LV-I 6 7838
23A 3 3000 C-LV-I 47592 1.00000 0.55852 0.17970 4716 14658
24X 3 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 958
25X 3 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1404
26X 3 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1682
27X 3 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1787
28X 3 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1572
29A 3 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7403 0.37956 0.16031 0.30620 4716 2469
30# tier=10000 train_toks=72679
31P 3 10000 LV-I MST 0.51454 0.51454 0.51454
32X 3 10000 C-LV-I 2 14967
33X 3 10000 C-LV-I 3 29823
34X 3 10000 C-LV-I 4 35555
35X 3 10000 C-LV-I 5 32186
36X 3 10000 C-LV-I 6 25476
37A 3 10000 C-LV-I 138007 1.00000 0.65119 0.16472 4716 18644
38X 3 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2111
39X 3 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4306
40X 3 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5796
41X 3 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6186
42X 3 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5292
43A 3 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 23691 0.42048 0.22689 0.30235 4716 3539
44# tier=30000 train_toks=218379
45P 3 30000 LV-I MST 0.53201 0.53201 0.53201
46X 3 30000 C-LV-I 2 32702
47X 3 30000 C-LV-I 3 71599
48X 3 30000 C-LV-I 4 96445
49X 3 30000 C-LV-I 5 92487
50X 3 30000 C-LV-I 6 75343
51A 3 30000 C-LV-I 368576 1.00000 0.71098 0.15519 4716 21606
52X 3 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 5047
53X 3 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 11804
54X 3 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 17283
55X 3 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 19451
56X 3 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16520
57A 3 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 70105 0.40310 0.26145 0.28080 4716 4391
58# seed=3 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=4908 kept=4908 gold=4908
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=4908 conn=4908 comp=4908
61# tier=3000 train_toks=21946
62P 3 3000 LV-A MST 0.45930 0.45930 0.45930
63X 3 3000 C-LV-A 2 8602
64X 3 3000 C-LV-A 3 13247
65X 3 3000 C-LV-A 4 12494
66X 3 3000 C-LV-A 5 10258
67X 3 3000 C-LV-A 6 7865
68A 3 3000 C-LV-A 52466 1.00000 0.43427 0.18063 4716 11338
69X 3 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1244
70X 3 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1479
71X 3 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1628
72X 3 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1686
73X 3 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1523
74A 3 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7560 0.37744 0.11705 0.32056 4716 1722
75# tier=10000 train_toks=72679
76P 3 10000 LV-A MST 0.53306 0.53306 0.53306
77X 3 10000 C-LV-A 2 17661
78X 3 10000 C-LV-A 3 35580
79X 3 10000 C-LV-A 4 38193
80X 3 10000 C-LV-A 5 33044
81X 3 10000 C-LV-A 6 25640
82A 3 10000 C-LV-A 150118 1.00000 0.56404 0.16515 4716 16107
83X 3 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 3008
84X 3 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 5056
85X 3 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 5927
86X 3 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6018
87X 3 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5241
88A 3 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25250 0.43766 0.20399 0.32099 4716 2997
89# tier=30000 train_toks=218379
90P 3 30000 LV-A MST 0.55012 0.55012 0.55012
91X 3 30000 C-LV-A 2 34558
92X 3 30000 C-LV-A 3 85788
93X 3 30000 C-LV-A 4 104425
94X 3 30000 C-LV-A 5 96252
95X 3 30000 C-LV-A 6 76263
96A 3 30000 C-LV-A 397286 1.00000 0.64822 0.15630 4716 19558
97X 3 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 6606
98X 3 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 13952
99X 3 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 17515
100X 3 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 18720
101X 3 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16341
102A 3 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 73134 0.40437 0.22392 0.28220 4716 3742
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-4.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 4 3000 LV-I 0.62460 0.71971 1185 0.53305 0.66917 0.76047
2N 4 3000 LV-I 83
3Q 4 3000 LV-A 0.72681 0.93997 1211 0.20084 0.87325 0.87325
4N 4 3000 LV-A 52
5Q 4 10000 LV-I 0.62664 0.71572 1180 0.50790 0.72955 0.72803
6N 4 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 4 10000 LV-A 0.72396 0.92425 1174 0.22117 0.78788 0.78788
8N 4 10000 LV-A 92
9Q 4 30000 LV-I 0.64554 0.73913 1206 0.49888 0.74441 0.74441
10N 4 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 4 30000 LV-A 0.72277 0.92006 1165 0.17575 0.83390 0.83390
12N 4 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=4 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=4900 kept=4900 gold=4900
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=4900 conn=4900 comp=4900
16# tier=3000 train_toks=21802
17P 4 3000 LV-I MST 0.44362 0.44362 0.44362
18X 4 3000 C-LV-I 2 6479
19X 4 3000 C-LV-I 3 10933
20X 4 3000 C-LV-I 4 11544
21X 4 3000 C-LV-I 5 9864
22X 4 3000 C-LV-I 6 7651
23A 4 3000 C-LV-I 46471 1.00000 0.56192 0.17888 4716 14814
24X 4 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 931
25X 4 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1312
26X 4 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1677
27X 4 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1828
28X 4 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1650
29A 4 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7398 0.36980 0.14695 0.30052 4716 2306
30# tier=10000 train_toks=72633
31P 4 10000 LV-I MST 0.50016 0.50016 0.50016
32X 4 10000 C-LV-I 2 14646
33X 4 10000 C-LV-I 3 29035
34X 4 10000 C-LV-I 4 34908
35X 4 10000 C-LV-I 5 31750
36X 4 10000 C-LV-I 6 25218
37A 4 10000 C-LV-I 135557 1.00000 0.64737 0.16190 4716 18857
38X 4 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2188
39X 4 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4235
40X 4 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5794
41X 4 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6259
42X 4 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5374
43A 4 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 23850 0.38316 0.20844 0.29006 4716 3389
44# tier=30000 train_toks=217946
45P 4 30000 LV-I MST 0.53371 0.53371 0.53371
46X 4 30000 C-LV-I 2 31046
47X 4 30000 C-LV-I 3 68770
48X 4 30000 C-LV-I 4 95115
49X 4 30000 C-LV-I 5 91963
50X 4 30000 C-LV-I 6 74968
51A 4 30000 C-LV-I 361862 1.00000 0.70420 0.15261 4716 21762
52X 4 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 5062
53X 4 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 11355
54X 4 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 17246
55X 4 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 19316
56X 4 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16347
57A 4 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 69326 0.39207 0.25021 0.28182 4716 4187
58# seed=4 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=4900 kept=4900 gold=4900
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=4900 conn=4900 comp=4900
61# tier=3000 train_toks=21802
62P 4 3000 LV-A MST 0.47100 0.47100 0.47100
63X 4 3000 C-LV-A 2 8079
64X 4 3000 C-LV-A 3 12880
65X 4 3000 C-LV-A 4 12243
66X 4 3000 C-LV-A 5 10062
67X 4 3000 C-LV-A 6 7668
68A 4 3000 C-LV-A 50932 1.00000 0.44847 0.18092 4716 11690
69X 4 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1228
70X 4 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1468
71X 4 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1604
72X 4 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1747
73X 4 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1618
74A 4 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7665 0.39334 0.14037 0.34425 4716 1923
75# tier=10000 train_toks=72633
76P 4 10000 LV-A MST 0.53079 0.53079 0.53079
77X 4 10000 C-LV-A 2 17718
78X 4 10000 C-LV-A 3 35541
79X 4 10000 C-LV-A 4 38009
80X 4 10000 C-LV-A 5 32874
81X 4 10000 C-LV-A 6 25459
82A 4 10000 C-LV-A 149601 1.00000 0.55322 0.16328 4716 15979
83X 4 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 3105
84X 4 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 4975
85X 4 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 5777
86X 4 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6222
87X 4 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5326
88A 4 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25405 0.43236 0.20568 0.31689 4716 3061
89# tier=30000 train_toks=217946
90P 4 30000 LV-A MST 0.57506 0.57506 0.57506
91X 4 30000 C-LV-A 2 36158
92X 4 30000 C-LV-A 3 89759
93X 4 30000 C-LV-A 4 107248
94X 4 30000 C-LV-A 5 96997
95X 4 30000 C-LV-A 6 76113
96A 4 30000 C-LV-A 406275 1.00000 0.62701 0.15692 4716 18844
97X 4 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 6940
98X 4 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 15012
99X 4 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 18903
100X 4 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 19468
101X 4 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16637
102A 4 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 76960 0.45123 0.26124 0.32125 4716 3835
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-5.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 5 3000 LV-I 0.64042 0.73263 1187 0.50375 0.88413 0.88413
2N 5 3000 LV-I 84
3Q 5 3000 LV-A 0.72344 0.93901 1219 0.12705 0.86855 0.86855
4N 5 3000 LV-A 51
5Q 5 10000 LV-I 0.65169 0.74972 1180 0.51771 0.72877 0.73004
6N 5 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 5 10000 LV-A 0.73125 0.94200 1187 0.18318 0.86248 0.86375
8N 5 10000 LV-A 86
9Q 5 30000 LV-I 0.63987 0.72749 1191 0.47548 0.69533 0.69346
10N 5 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 5 30000 LV-A 0.71919 0.91157 1166 0.26799 0.82492 0.82492
12N 5 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=5 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=4953 kept=4953 gold=4953
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=4953 conn=4953 comp=4953
16# tier=3000 train_toks=21900
17P 5 3000 LV-I MST 0.45313 0.45313 0.45313
18X 5 3000 C-LV-I 2 6626
19X 5 3000 C-LV-I 3 11191
20X 5 3000 C-LV-I 4 11663
21X 5 3000 C-LV-I 5 9974
22X 5 3000 C-LV-I 6 7746
23A 5 3000 C-LV-I 47200 1.00000 0.55855 0.17628 4757 15073
24X 5 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 930
25X 5 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1284
26X 5 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1689
27X 5 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1864
28X 5 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1600
29A 5 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7367 0.37566 0.16229 0.30929 4757 2496
30# tier=10000 train_toks=73066
31P 5 10000 LV-I MST 0.51476 0.51476 0.51476
32X 5 10000 C-LV-I 2 14525
33X 5 10000 C-LV-I 3 28410
34X 5 10000 C-LV-I 4 34643
35X 5 10000 C-LV-I 5 31883
36X 5 10000 C-LV-I 6 25553
37A 5 10000 C-LV-I 135014 1.00000 0.66975 0.16417 4757 19407
38X 5 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2133
39X 5 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4263
40X 5 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5838
41X 5 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6449
42X 5 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5343
43A 5 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 24026 0.40341 0.23166 0.30484 4757 3615
44# tier=30000 train_toks=218533
45P 5 30000 LV-I MST 0.53816 0.53816 0.53816
46X 5 30000 C-LV-I 2 29438
47X 5 30000 C-LV-I 3 65832
48X 5 30000 C-LV-I 4 92401
49X 5 30000 C-LV-I 5 91124
50X 5 30000 C-LV-I 6 75259
51A 5 30000 C-LV-I 354054 1.00000 0.73597 0.15440 4757 22675
52X 5 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 4555
53X 5 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 10976
54X 5 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 16873
55X 5 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 18950
56X 5 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16249
57A 5 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 67603 0.40782 0.26824 0.29179 4757 4373
58# seed=5 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=4953 kept=4953 gold=4953
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=4953 conn=4953 comp=4953
61# tier=3000 train_toks=21900
62P 5 3000 LV-A MST 0.46225 0.46225 0.46225
63X 5 3000 C-LV-A 2 8406
64X 5 3000 C-LV-A 3 13079
65X 5 3000 C-LV-A 4 12391
66X 5 3000 C-LV-A 5 10164
67X 5 3000 C-LV-A 6 7767
68A 5 3000 C-LV-A 51807 1.00000 0.43115 0.17833 4757 11501
69X 5 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1225
70X 5 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1390
71X 5 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1585
72X 5 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1762
73X 5 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1577
74A 5 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7539 0.37040 0.12003 0.32278 4757 1769
75# tier=10000 train_toks=73066
76P 5 10000 LV-A MST 0.53146 0.53146 0.53146
77X 5 10000 C-LV-A 2 18045
78X 5 10000 C-LV-A 3 36097
79X 5 10000 C-LV-A 4 38304
80X 5 10000 C-LV-A 5 33242
81X 5 10000 C-LV-A 6 25785
82A 5 10000 C-LV-A 151473 1.00000 0.55581 0.16536 4757 15989
83X 5 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 3112
84X 5 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 5004
85X 5 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 5930
86X 5 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6260
87X 5 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5332
88A 5 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25638 0.41623 0.19760 0.31105 4757 3022
89# tier=30000 train_toks=218533
90P 5 30000 LV-A MST 0.57857 0.57857 0.57857
91X 5 30000 C-LV-A 2 34491
92X 5 30000 C-LV-A 3 85845
93X 5 30000 C-LV-A 4 106121
94X 5 30000 C-LV-A 5 97351
95X 5 30000 C-LV-A 6 76794
96A 5 30000 C-LV-A 400602 1.00000 0.65209 0.15870 4757 19546
97X 5 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 6786
98X 5 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 14483
99X 5 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 18840
100X 5 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 19275
101X 5 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16240
102A 5 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 75624 0.45155 0.26319 0.31955 4757 3918
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-6.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 6 3000 LV-I 0.61910 0.71037 1183 0.53129 0.78864 0.78864
2N 6 3000 LV-I 85
3Q 6 3000 LV-A 0.72529 0.95094 1241 0.09996 0.88854 0.88854
4N 6 3000 LV-A 35
5Q 6 10000 LV-I 0.65183 0.73695 1185 0.48777 0.72465 0.72465
6N 6 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 6 10000 LV-A 0.72453 0.93543 1169 0.19179 0.88310 0.88310
8N 6 10000 LV-A 100
9Q 6 30000 LV-I 0.64738 0.73900 1179 0.49358 0.65088 0.65088
10N 6 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 6 30000 LV-A 0.71796 0.92095 1176 0.29995 0.84912 0.84912
12N 6 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=6 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=5030 kept=5030 gold=5030
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=5030 conn=5030 comp=5030
16# tier=3000 train_toks=22127
17P 6 3000 LV-I MST 0.44049 0.44049 0.44049
18X 6 3000 C-LV-I 2 6525
19X 6 3000 C-LV-I 3 11009
20X 6 3000 C-LV-I 4 11719
21X 6 3000 C-LV-I 5 10149
22X 6 3000 C-LV-I 6 7949
23A 6 3000 C-LV-I 47351 1.00000 0.55510 0.17485 4828 15327
24X 6 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 873
25X 6 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1303
26X 6 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1713
27X 6 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1800
28X 6 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1534
29A 6 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7223 0.36765 0.14561 0.28942 4828 2429
30# tier=10000 train_toks=73282
31P 6 10000 LV-I MST 0.50190 0.50190 0.50190
32X 6 10000 C-LV-I 2 14631
33X 6 10000 C-LV-I 3 29212
34X 6 10000 C-LV-I 4 35115
35X 6 10000 C-LV-I 5 32338
36X 6 10000 C-LV-I 6 25830
37A 6 10000 C-LV-I 137126 1.00000 0.64354 0.15933 4828 19500
38X 6 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2066
39X 6 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4111
40X 6 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5794
41X 6 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6332
42X 6 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5338
43A 6 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 23641 0.39312 0.21437 0.28822 4828 3591
44# tier=30000 train_toks=217426
45P 6 30000 LV-I MST 0.56458 0.56458 0.56458
46X 6 30000 C-LV-I 2 30198
47X 6 30000 C-LV-I 3 67714
48X 6 30000 C-LV-I 4 93206
49X 6 30000 C-LV-I 5 90499
50X 6 30000 C-LV-I 6 74303
51A 6 30000 C-LV-I 355920 1.00000 0.71520 0.15123 4828 22833
52X 6 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 4908
53X 6 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 11390
54X 6 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 17112
55X 6 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 18616
56X 6 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16368
57A 6 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 68394 0.43186 0.28065 0.31748 4828 4268
58# seed=6 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=5030 kept=5030 gold=5030
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=5030 conn=5030 comp=5030
61# tier=3000 train_toks=22127
62P 6 3000 LV-A MST 0.46114 0.46114 0.46114
63X 6 3000 C-LV-A 2 8563
64X 6 3000 C-LV-A 3 13284
65X 6 3000 C-LV-A 4 12638
66X 6 3000 C-LV-A 5 10384
67X 6 3000 C-LV-A 6 7985
68A 6 3000 C-LV-A 52854 1.00000 0.41839 0.17674 4828 11429
69X 6 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1248
70X 6 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1368
71X 6 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1694
72X 6 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1689
73X 6 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1517
74A 6 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7516 0.37179 0.11330 0.31970 4828 1711
75# tier=10000 train_toks=73282
76P 6 10000 LV-A MST 0.52825 0.52825 0.52825
77X 6 10000 C-LV-A 2 18179
78X 6 10000 C-LV-A 3 36142
79X 6 10000 C-LV-A 4 38747
80X 6 10000 C-LV-A 5 33648
81X 6 10000 C-LV-A 6 26063
82A 6 10000 C-LV-A 152779 1.00000 0.53500 0.15928 4828 16217
83X 6 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 3083
84X 6 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 5004
85X 6 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 5937
86X 6 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6131
87X 6 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5257
88A 6 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25412 0.42357 0.18683 0.30279 4828 2979
89# tier=30000 train_toks=217426
90P 6 30000 LV-A MST 0.56505 0.56505 0.56505
91X 6 30000 C-LV-A 2 36120
92X 6 30000 C-LV-A 3 89005
93X 6 30000 C-LV-A 4 105885
94X 6 30000 C-LV-A 5 96182
95X 6 30000 C-LV-A 6 75682
96A 6 30000 C-LV-A 402874 1.00000 0.61392 0.15331 4828 19333
97X 6 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 7134
98X 6 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 14481
99X 6 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 18353
100X 6 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 18983
101X 6 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16458
102A 6 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 75409 0.44428 0.24337 0.31003 4828 3790
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-7.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 7 3000 LV-I 0.62595 0.71832 1207 0.49019 0.77935 0.77935
2N 7 3000 LV-I 73
3Q 7 3000 LV-A 0.71801 0.92849 1221 0.12700 0.81478 0.81478
4N 7 3000 LV-A 58
5Q 7 10000 LV-I 0.62627 0.71686 1198 0.49532 0.74378 0.74378
6N 7 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 7 10000 LV-A 0.72746 0.92967 1188 0.23847 0.82650 0.82650
8N 7 10000 LV-A 100
9Q 7 30000 LV-I 0.64799 0.75307 1215 0.46924 0.74851 0.74917
10N 7 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 7 30000 LV-A 0.72434 0.93098 1190 0.19519 0.79562 0.79562
12N 7 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=7 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=4942 kept=4942 gold=4942
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=4942 conn=4942 comp=4942
16# tier=3000 train_toks=22049
17P 7 3000 LV-I MST 0.45212 0.45212 0.45212
18X 7 3000 C-LV-I 2 6325
19X 7 3000 C-LV-I 3 10962
20X 7 3000 C-LV-I 4 11641
21X 7 3000 C-LV-I 5 10033
22X 7 3000 C-LV-I 6 7802
23A 7 3000 C-LV-I 46763 1.00000 0.56528 0.17324 4764 15545
24X 7 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 867
25X 7 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1379
26X 7 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1813
27X 7 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1882
28X 7 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1514
29A 7 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7455 0.38182 0.15638 0.29681 4764 2510
30# tier=10000 train_toks=73005
31P 7 10000 LV-I MST 0.48844 0.48844 0.48844
32X 7 10000 C-LV-I 2 14950
33X 7 10000 C-LV-I 3 29677
34X 7 10000 C-LV-I 4 35545
35X 7 10000 C-LV-I 5 32250
36X 7 10000 C-LV-I 6 25518
37A 7 10000 C-LV-I 137940 1.00000 0.65575 0.16526 4764 18904
38X 7 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2142
39X 7 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4317
40X 7 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5943
41X 7 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6389
42X 7 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5358
43A 7 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 24149 0.37993 0.20361 0.29138 4764 3329
44# tier=30000 train_toks=217853
45P 7 30000 LV-I MST 0.54514 0.54514 0.54514
46X 7 30000 C-LV-I 2 29583
47X 7 30000 C-LV-I 3 66294
48X 7 30000 C-LV-I 4 92267
49X 7 30000 C-LV-I 5 90322
50X 7 30000 C-LV-I 6 74399
51A 7 30000 C-LV-I 352865 1.00000 0.73174 0.15603 4764 22342
52X 7 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 4686
53X 7 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 11509
54X 7 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 17186
55X 7 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 19229
56X 7 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16289
57A 7 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 68899 0.41037 0.26868 0.29935 4764 4276
58# seed=7 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=4942 kept=4942 gold=4942
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=4942 conn=4942 comp=4942
61# tier=3000 train_toks=22049
62P 7 3000 LV-A MST 0.46662 0.46662 0.46662
63X 7 3000 C-LV-A 2 8344
64X 7 3000 C-LV-A 3 13162
65X 7 3000 C-LV-A 4 12484
66X 7 3000 C-LV-A 5 10259
67X 7 3000 C-LV-A 6 7831
68A 7 3000 C-LV-A 52080 1.00000 0.42380 0.17018 4764 11864
69X 7 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1201
70X 7 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1461
71X 7 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1701
72X 7 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1767
73X 7 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1498
74A 7 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7628 0.37762 0.11566 0.30748 4764 1792
75# tier=10000 train_toks=73005
76P 7 10000 LV-A MST 0.52670 0.52670 0.52670
77X 7 10000 C-LV-A 2 18054
78X 7 10000 C-LV-A 3 36089
79X 7 10000 C-LV-A 4 38608
80X 7 10000 C-LV-A 5 33328
81X 7 10000 C-LV-A 6 25715
82A 7 10000 C-LV-A 151794 1.00000 0.54954 0.16320 4764 16042
83X 7 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 3071
84X 7 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 5092
85X 7 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 6003
86X 7 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6144
87X 7 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5279
88A 7 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25589 0.42527 0.19605 0.31061 4764 3007
89# tier=30000 train_toks=217853
90P 7 30000 LV-A MST 0.57735 0.57735 0.57735
91X 7 30000 C-LV-A 2 35972
92X 7 30000 C-LV-A 3 89514
93X 7 30000 C-LV-A 4 106674
94X 7 30000 C-LV-A 5 96582
95X 7 30000 C-LV-A 6 75852
96A 7 30000 C-LV-A 404594 1.00000 0.62930 0.15713 4764 19080
97X 7 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 7127
98X 7 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 15098
99X 7 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 18951
100X 7 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 19435
101X 7 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16404
102A 7 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 77015 0.44836 0.25420 0.31324 4764 3866
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-8.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 8 3000 LV-I 0.63533 0.71733 1176 0.50579 0.66132 0.66132
2N 8 3000 LV-I 96
3Q 8 3000 LV-A 0.71509 0.90954 1169 0.21098 0.81226 0.81226
4N 8 3000 LV-A 73
5Q 8 10000 LV-I 0.61535 0.68240 1167 0.54777 0.62545 0.60954
6N 8 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 8 10000 LV-A 0.71974 0.90848 1144 0.23709 0.83008 0.83008
8N 8 10000 LV-A 100
9Q 8 30000 LV-I 0.64756 0.72707 1170 0.46105 0.68695 0.68695
10N 8 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 8 30000 LV-A 0.72643 0.91116 1162 0.28966 0.83638 0.83638
12N 8 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=8 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=4825 kept=4825 gold=4825
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=4825 conn=4825 comp=4825
16# tier=3000 train_toks=21908
17P 8 3000 LV-I MST 0.44093 0.44093 0.44093
18X 8 3000 C-LV-I 2 6718
19X 8 3000 C-LV-I 3 11390
20X 8 3000 C-LV-I 4 11822
21X 8 3000 C-LV-I 5 10067
22X 8 3000 C-LV-I 6 7800
23A 8 3000 C-LV-I 47797 1.00000 0.56275 0.18419 4661 14241
24X 8 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 951
25X 8 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1380
26X 8 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1604
27X 8 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1781
28X 8 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1571
29A 8 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7287 0.38061 0.16005 0.32350 4661 2306
30# tier=10000 train_toks=72661
31P 8 10000 LV-I MST 0.50000 0.50000 0.50000
32X 8 10000 C-LV-I 2 14166
33X 8 10000 C-LV-I 3 28221
34X 8 10000 C-LV-I 4 34249
35X 8 10000 C-LV-I 5 31674
36X 8 10000 C-LV-I 6 25345
37A 8 10000 C-LV-I 133655 1.00000 0.68805 0.16681 4661 19225
38X 8 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2062
39X 8 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4104
40X 8 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5473
41X 8 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6097
42X 8 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5211
43A 8 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 22947 0.37696 0.21519 0.29491 4661 3401
44# tier=30000 train_toks=217378
45P 8 30000 LV-I MST 0.53837 0.53837 0.53837
46X 8 30000 C-LV-I 2 29397
47X 8 30000 C-LV-I 3 66575
48X 8 30000 C-LV-I 4 91985
49X 8 30000 C-LV-I 5 90036
50X 8 30000 C-LV-I 6 74032
51A 8 30000 C-LV-I 352025 1.00000 0.74233 0.15605 4661 22172
52X 8 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 4689
53X 8 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 11246
54X 8 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 17135
55X 8 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 19068
56X 8 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16033
57A 8 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 68171 0.41193 0.27591 0.29625 4661 4341
58# seed=8 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=4825 kept=4825 gold=4825
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=4825 conn=4825 comp=4825
61# tier=3000 train_toks=21908
62P 8 3000 LV-A MST 0.46098 0.46098 0.46098
63X 8 3000 C-LV-A 2 8111
64X 8 3000 C-LV-A 3 12871
65X 8 3000 C-LV-A 4 12282
66X 8 3000 C-LV-A 5 10182
67X 8 3000 C-LV-A 6 7812
68A 8 3000 C-LV-A 51258 1.00000 0.43424 0.17061 4661 11863
69X 8 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1247
70X 8 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1398
71X 8 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1527
72X 8 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1693
73X 8 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1531
74A 8 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7396 0.37524 0.12336 0.29700 4661 1936
75# tier=10000 train_toks=72661
76P 8 10000 LV-A MST 0.53697 0.53697 0.53697
77X 8 10000 C-LV-A 2 17740
78X 8 10000 C-LV-A 3 35429
79X 8 10000 C-LV-A 4 38088
80X 8 10000 C-LV-A 5 33014
81X 8 10000 C-LV-A 6 25573
82A 8 10000 C-LV-A 149844 1.00000 0.55610 0.16246 4661 15955
83X 8 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 3129
84X 8 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 4960
85X 8 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 5687
86X 8 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6019
87X 8 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5277
88A 8 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25072 0.43381 0.19867 0.31422 4661 2947
89# tier=30000 train_toks=217378
90P 8 30000 LV-A MST 0.57994 0.57994 0.57994
91X 8 30000 C-LV-A 2 35182
92X 8 30000 C-LV-A 3 84495
93X 8 30000 C-LV-A 4 103747
94X 8 30000 C-LV-A 5 95202
95X 8 30000 C-LV-A 6 75397
96A 8 30000 C-LV-A 394023 1.00000 0.64814 0.15502 4661 19488
97X 8 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 7084
98X 8 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 14201
99X 8 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 18172
100X 8 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 18821
101X 8 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16092
102A 8 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 74370 0.45441 0.26089 0.31568 4661 3852
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/seed-9.tsv +102 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,102 @@
1Q 9 3000 LV-I 0.61107 0.69947 1170 0.53434 0.87336 0.83388
2N 9 3000 LV-I 86
3Q 9 3000 LV-A 0.72381 0.94872 1209 0.12965 0.88569 0.88569
4N 9 3000 LV-A 53
5Q 9 10000 LV-I 0.64551 0.71984 1159 0.56725 0.69121 0.69666
6N 9 10000 LV-I 100
7Q 9 10000 LV-A 0.72661 0.93583 1187 0.16728 0.87935 0.87935
8N 9 10000 LV-A 76
9Q 9 30000 LV-I 0.65126 0.75961 1190 0.45901 0.80148 0.76727
10N 9 30000 LV-I 100
11Q 9 30000 LV-A 0.73101 0.92232 1157 0.27843 0.85312 0.85312
12N 9 30000 LV-A 100
13# seed=9 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
14GUARD C1 PASS tp=4964 kept=4964 gold=4964
15GUARD C5 PASS gold=4964 conn=4964 comp=4964
16# tier=3000 train_toks=22082
17P 9 3000 LV-I MST 0.44558 0.44558 0.44558
18X 9 3000 C-LV-I 2 6136
19X 9 3000 C-LV-I 3 10494
20X 9 3000 C-LV-I 4 11449
21X 9 3000 C-LV-I 5 10004
22X 9 3000 C-LV-I 6 7905
23A 9 3000 C-LV-I 45988 1.00000 0.59021 0.17668 4800 16035
24X 9 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 867
25X 9 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 1324
26X 9 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 1674
27X 9 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 1811
28X 9 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 1570
29A 9 3000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 7246 0.36167 0.14917 0.29996 4800 2387
30# tier=10000 train_toks=73202
31P 9 10000 LV-I MST 0.52482 0.52482 0.52482
32X 9 10000 C-LV-I 2 14944
33X 9 10000 C-LV-I 3 29736
34X 9 10000 C-LV-I 4 35636
35X 9 10000 C-LV-I 5 32472
36X 9 10000 C-LV-I 6 25814
37A 9 10000 C-LV-I 138602 1.00000 0.66063 0.16801 4800 18874
38X 9 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 2200
39X 9 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 4302
40X 9 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 5932
41X 9 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 6284
42X 9 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 5475
43A 9 10000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 24193 0.42125 0.23708 0.32147 4800 3540
44# tier=30000 train_toks=217891
45P 9 30000 LV-I MST 0.54461 0.54461 0.54461
46X 9 30000 C-LV-I 2 30562
47X 9 30000 C-LV-I 3 69301
48X 9 30000 C-LV-I 4 95368
49X 9 30000 C-LV-I 5 91921
50X 9 30000 C-LV-I 6 74898
51A 9 30000 C-LV-I 362050 1.00000 0.72042 0.15631 4800 22123
52X 9 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 2 4971
53X 9 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 3 11664
54X 9 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 4 17700
55X 9 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 5 19545
56X 9 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 6 16423
57A 9 30000 M-LV-I-ucomp-MST 70303 0.39917 0.26667 0.30375 4800 4214
58# seed=9 V=1607 heldout_sents=2000
59GUARD C1 PASS tp=4964 kept=4964 gold=4964
60GUARD C5 PASS gold=4964 conn=4964 comp=4964
61# tier=3000 train_toks=22082
62P 9 3000 LV-A MST 0.46513 0.46513 0.46513
63X 9 3000 C-LV-A 2 8365
64X 9 3000 C-LV-A 3 13124
65X 9 3000 C-LV-A 4 12549
66X 9 3000 C-LV-A 5 10344
67X 9 3000 C-LV-A 6 7948
68A 9 3000 C-LV-A 52330 1.00000 0.42042 0.17167 4800 11755
69X 9 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 1221
70X 9 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 1453
71X 9 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 1656
72X 9 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 1742
73X 9 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 1561
74A 9 3000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 7633 0.36542 0.11667 0.31674 4800 1768
75# tier=10000 train_toks=73202
76P 9 10000 LV-A MST 0.51983 0.51983 0.51983
77X 9 10000 C-LV-A 2 18640
78X 9 10000 C-LV-A 3 36980
79X 9 10000 C-LV-A 4 39160
80X 9 10000 C-LV-A 5 33622
81X 9 10000 C-LV-A 6 26019
82A 9 10000 C-LV-A 154421 1.00000 0.54042 0.16557 4800 15667
83X 9 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 3204
84X 9 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 4917
85X 9 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 6039
86X 9 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 6121
87X 9 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 5498
88A 9 10000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 25779 0.41063 0.18792 0.31330 4800 2879
89# tier=30000 train_toks=217891
90P 9 30000 LV-A MST 0.58909 0.58909 0.58909
91X 9 30000 C-LV-A 2 34411
92X 9 30000 C-LV-A 3 83869
93X 9 30000 C-LV-A 4 103627
94X 9 30000 C-LV-A 5 95828
95X 9 30000 C-LV-A 6 75925
96A 9 30000 C-LV-A 393660 1.00000 0.65208 0.15652 4800 19998
97X 9 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 2 6802
98X 9 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 3 14303
99X 9 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 4 18435
100X 9 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 5 19398
101X 9 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 6 16462
102A 9 30000 M-LV-A-ucomp-MST 75400 0.46979 0.27729 0.32970 4800 4037
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/src.sha256 +4 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
151b048cf6c0a2689019ae8502a349e257733853f72fd1f12e9fd1a96ec8bb816 l2.c
2d836689422948fa141f5a5981082a9b563246adbbb39514996a63219c648d3dd lv.py
3577e806dc7c1942cd5624cecd81f48baaa5f19e81add39602fca7edde8f24fee ../ladder/port/cluster.c
42f4343faaa8bd25592fdadbc5bd38807f63d6823bcf85aff9eaeda50e96b8396 ../across-cluster/ac.c
experiments/level2/results-LV/1792366731/summary.txt +24 -0
……@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
1## Held-out labels (mean): V-measure / many-to-one / labels / share in a class / sense / sense-COLL / merges
23000 LV-I: 0.622 / 0.712 / 1180.700 / 0.532 / 0.748 / 0.758 / 88.8
33000 LV-A: 0.720 / 0.933 / 1211.300 / 0.164 / 0.855 / 0.855 / 56.1
410000 LV-I: 0.637 / 0.720 / 1178.100 / 0.520 / 0.704 / 0.735 / 100.0
510000 LV-A: 0.726 / 0.929 / 1172.300 / 0.227 / 0.842 / 0.842 / 93.8
630000 LV-I: 0.658 / 0.759 / 1190.000 / 0.472 / 0.753 / 0.750 / 100.0
730000 LV-A: 0.722 / 0.918 / 1170.200 / 0.255 / 0.828 / 0.828 / 100.0
8
9## Re-parse link F1 and level 2 (mean): link F1 / ucomp types / ucomp type recall / ucomp precision
103000 words(round 0) F1 0.455 ucomp recall 0.113; L-MST F1 0.626
11 LV-I: 0.449 / 7379 / 0.157 / 0.308
12 LV-A: 0.462 / 7569 / 0.121 / 0.319
1310000 words(round 0) F1 0.514 ucomp recall 0.185; L-MST F1 0.689
14 LV-I: 0.504 / 23820 / 0.213 / 0.296
15 LV-A: 0.528 / 25433 / 0.198 / 0.315
1630000 words(round 0) F1 0.570 ucomp recall 0.254; L-MST F1 0.700
17 LV-I: 0.544 / 69388 / 0.267 / 0.296
18 LV-A: 0.572 / 75680 / 0.256 / 0.316
19
20## Predictions (at 30000)
21L1: FAIL — sense LV-I − LV-I-COLL +0.003 [-0.004, +0.011]
22L2: FAIL — link F1 LV-I − word MST -0.026 [-0.035, -0.016]
23L3: FAIL — link F1 LV-I − L-MST -0.156 [-0.169, -0.144] (bar: lower > -0.02)
24L4: PASS — ucomp type recall LV-I − word MST +0.013 [+0.005, +0.021]
experiments/level2/summarize-LV.py +1 -1
……@@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ def load (d):
1515 p = line.rstrip('\n').split('\t')
1616 if p[0] == 'Q': Q[(int(p[2]), p[3], int(p[1]))] = tuple(map(float, p[4:10]))
1717 elif p[0] == 'N': N[(int(p[2]), p[3], int(p[1]))] = int(p[4])
18 elif p[0] == 'P': P[(int(p[2]), p[3], int(p[1]))] = float(p[7])
18 elif p[0] == 'P' and p[4] == 'MST': P[(int(p[2]), p[3], int(p[1]))] = float(p[7]) # MST rows only
1919 elif p[0] == 'A': A[(int(p[2]), p[3], int(p[1]))] = (int(p[4]), float(p[6]), float(p[7]))
2020 elif p[0] == 'RP': RP[(int(p[2]), int(p[3]), int(p[1]))] = float(p[6])
2121 return Q, N, P, A, RP